Is the American Dream ("the Dream") dead? The Dream posits that success results from work and sacrifice rather than the circumstances in which one is born. However, in recent years, some have argued that the so-called Dream is illusory, used only as a "strategic and intricate device crafted to keep you where you are." Antagonists propose that the Dream only adds wealth to the rich while keeping dream-chasers on the hamster wheel.
The Dream can be measured by analyzing generational mobility, which refers to whether an individual's social and economic opportunities depend upon their parents' income or social status. Less generational mobility suggests that the Dream is dead or dying, and more mobility indicates the opposite. Upward mobility means that an individual was born to parents in the bottom 25% of income earners and that they later fall within the top 25% of income earners in America.
According to most data, residents of rural counties are more likely to be persistently poor, with at least a 20 percent poverty rate persisting for at least 30 years. As reported by The Wall Street Journal, "In terms of poverty, college attainment, teenage births, divorce, death rates from heart disease and cancer, reliance on federal disability insurance and male labor-force participation, rural counties now rank the worst."
According to some researchers, five factors directly correlate with generational mobility: (1) residential segregation, (2) income inequality, (3) school quality, (4) social capital, and (5) family structure. Rural counties have lower incomes, levels of educational attainment, life expectancies, and limited access to health insurance and healthcare providers than their urban counterparts. Why, then, do some rural counties have the highest upward mobility rates in the country but also some of the lowest?
Perhaps another factor—the ease of migration from rural communities to urban ones—can explain this seeming disparity. Is the solution to "attaining" the Dream to be born into a rural community and leave as soon as possible for an urban one? If leaving is the only answer, should the Dream even be considered a dream?
Supposing that achieving the Dream for rural people is premised on leaving their community, each pursuit diminishes the Dream for those left behind. If the best and brightest pursue education or economic opportunities elsewhere, growth remains stagnant for the home community. Published by The Sun, a U.C. Davis law student references Fresno's inability to attract educated professionals, a phenomenon called "brain drain," the migration of educated and skilled individuals away from their home region. His solution to attract young professionals includes increasing career opportunities, housing, arts, entertainment, and sports.
While stagnant growth may be one side effect of the Dream, one more insidious issue is the Dream's tarnishing effect. If everyone can succeed, why do unsuccessful people exist? Like Vice President J.D. Vance, proponents of the Dream argue that lack of success results from laziness. However, those proponents forget what the evidence proves—a lack of resources impacts the likelihood of success. Often, proponents of the Dream ignore their privilege to bolster their ego and achievements.
Like most things, the Dream may be aspirational in most parts of America. Nevertheless, it seemingly impedes and damages rural America's vitality. It is okay to recognize that dreams vary between people and places. Arguably, for rural America, the question is not whether the Dream is dead but whether it should be.
3 comments:
This is a really interesting perspective. I have personally felt like the American Dream is more myth than reality and that a lot truly depends on where you start in life and what resources are already available to you. I usually conceive of the harm of the "American Dream" in a more abstract way as it operates as a promise to keep people working and hopeful that if they just work hard enough, they will be rewarded with an idyllic life. The harm you talk about is far more tangible and its interesting to think about how the promise drains rural communities of people pursuing success.
there are various steps involved in recovering of crypto from a stolen wallet or person , before you can get into this process, you must make sure you have the guidance of a professional like, Expert Bernie Doran,Berniedoransignals@gmailcom in crypto recovery process and then follow the procedures carefully , it’s not an easy task , but trust the process , what matters is that your lost funds will be recovered
Good morning. I discussed in good detail yesterday the scenarios for this weekends storm system. I mentioned how this would either end up pulling north too early causing widespread rain or stay south and roll across the east causing more winter weather. At this time scenario two is becoming more likely but New England is the main target for a snowstorm.
The lack of professionals, such as attorneys, can inhibit economic growth in many of these rural places [https://www.ruraljusticecollaborative.org/areas-of-focus/eliminate-barriers-to-justice#:~:text=Lack%20of%20legal%20representation%20in,economic%20growth%20in%20rural%20communities.]. This only exacerbates the poverty issues in these communities, especially since many of these rural residents lack access to justice. Although professionals are given many incentives to stay within these communities, it is not enough to keep them there.
Post a Comment