Saturday, February 9, 2013

Law and Order in the Ozarks (Part CXII): Groceries and guns

The Feb. 6, 2013 issue of the Newton County Times reports on several major happenings, with the lead story being the re-naming of Bob's AG Supermarket after its purchase by the Harp's chain, based in Springdale, Arkansas.  Bob's had operated in Jasper since 1967 and is the grocery store I grew up with, having also gone to school with Bob's children.  The good news is that Jasper still has a grocery store and residents are not forced to go to Harrison, 20 miles away, for groceries.  Read reports about the demise of rural grocery stores here and here.

In more substantive news, the Quorum Court (equivalent of a Board of Supervisors) adopted Resolution No. 13-01, "A Resolution Supporting the Individual Right to Bear Arms as Established by the Second Amendment to the Constitution of the United Staes of America and Supported by the Laws of Nature and God for Survival and Self Defense."  The resolution is similar to a non-binding resolution approved by Arkansas's state lawmakers last month, urging the federal government not to limit Second Amendment rights.  Among other things, the resolution states:
WHEREAS, the individual right to keep and bear arms is fully germane to the right to life-survival and self defense and the right of liberty ...
At the same meeting the Quorum Court appropriated funds to the Sheriff's office for "computers and to help meet detention costs."  The appropriations included $3,603 from the a Northwest Arkansas Economic Development District grant for the purchase of computers that law enforcement officers can use in the field, as was phone signal boosters.  The Quorum Court also appropriated $793.48 received from the state for unclaimed property and $15,300 in general funds to the County Special Detention Fund.  The County has received $34,061.94 from the federal government for the "purpose of patrolling and rescuing on government lands, of which $4,200 is in service contracts for local fire departments, and the remainder is Tittle III budget funds for personal services.

In other news, the Arkansas Dept. of Rural Services awarded $61,000 to the Jasper Volunteer Fire Department for the purchase of a new tanker truck.

U.S. Congressman Tim Cotton has set a townhall meeting for February 9 at the Huntsville City Hall.

Amish sect leader sentenced to 15 years for religion-based hate crimes

Samuel Mullett, Sr., the leader of a breakaway sect of Amish in Bergholz, Ohio, was sentenced to 15 years in relation to his conviction of federal hate crimes for forcibly cutting the hair and beards of Amish not part of his faction, which is 18 families strong.  Fifteen of Mullett's followers, including three of his sons and their wives, were also convicted of related offenses, but they received shorter sentences, ranging from one year and one day (for most of the six women defendants) to seven years.  The prosecutor had recommended a life sentence for the elder Mullett, who was said to have coordinated the assaults even though he did not participate in any of them.

Reports of sentencing indicate that the elder Mullett asked that he serve all of the defendants' sentences so that the four couples involved could "go home to their families, raise their children."  The New York Times report included this further detail of the sentencing.
Another defendant, Lester Miller, apologized before the sentencing to his parents, whom he and others, including his wife, Elizabeth Miller, had attacked. He asked the judge to spare his wife, “to put her sentence on me,” so she could care for their 11 children, according to WKYC-TV.
Other defendants asked the judge to give them all or part of the elder Mullett's sentence.

Eyder Peralta's story about the matter, for NPR, is here.  The New York Times coverage is here.  Earlier blog posts about the events are here and here.

Friday, February 8, 2013

Jerry Brown's day in the country

The Sacramento Bee reported yesterday on Jerry Brown's visit to Colusa, California, population 5,971.
Gov. Jerry Brown knew the room was against him when he showed up for a farm show here Wednesday. 
But Brown has a controversial water project to promote and is trying to make inroads in rural California. He put on a flannel shirt and opened with a joke. 
"I checked out the voting history of Colusa County," Brown said. 
Not only has the county opposed the Democratic governor every time he has been on a ballot, Brown said, but it overwhelmingly voted against a similar, unsuccessful, water plan Brown championed when he was governor before, in 1982.
* * *
Later – after Brown had toured the farm show, sat on a tractor and announced that he will build a house on family land nearby – even his second cousin's reaction suggested how difficult it may be for Brown to find support among area farmers for his $14 billion plan. Brown is proposing to build two tunnels to divert water around the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to the south.
* * *
Appearing at a farm show in a rural, relatively tiny county is indicative of how significant the project is to the governor.
Wow, I guess a California governor has to be pretty desperate about something really important--like water for southern Californians--to spend time visiting a rural area, even paying lipservice to their interests and concerns.

The story concludes:
Following Brown's address, he made small talk with farmers and exhibitors as he strode through the grounds. Brown ate a few prunes, asked about machinery and appeared all but ready, at one booth, to purchase a flagpole. 
At the suggestion of first lady Anne Gust Brown, the governor put his dog, Sutter, on a tractor. His wife told him it would make good "publicity for the (farm) show."

Read more here: http://www.sacbee.com/2013/02/07/5171621/brown-enters-hostile-territory.html#storylink=cpy
Colusa is the county seat of Colusa County, population 21,419, which is one California's six original counties.  

In other rural news, it was revealed this week that the Brown administration has been using funds from the controversial rural fire protection fee to investigate and "chase" fire starters, a practice the Office of Legislative Counsel views as a violation of state law.  Read more here.  Some background on the fee is here.  Now, Brown has posted a bill that would permit the state to use the fire fund "beyond where fee payers live." His bill would "additionally include fire projects in areas that immediately threaten state responsibility areas." Meanwhile, Republican legislators are proposing to eliminate the fee altogether.  Read more here. Currently, about 825,000 rural home owners pay the $150 annual fee.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Small town as "super-human"?

Yes, I know that small towns are not human, let alone super human, but this recent headline from the New York Times seems to anthropomorphize a particular town in Alabama--the one where a standoff between a mentally ill man who abducted a young child and local police ended a few days go.  The headline for the story by Campbell Robertson and Robbie Brown is "Small Town Wins Its Standoff with Kidnapper," and the tone is somewhat similar to the Times earlier reporting about the Midland City, Alabama incident.  (See this prior post).  Not only does the Robertson-Brown story treat Midland City, population 1,703, as a homogeneous and cohesive unit, like prior NYT coverage of the kidnapping, it focuses on religion.  Here's an excerpt that refers to the fact that the boy kidnapped, Ethan, had an assigned seat on the bus from which he was kidnapped, a seat with his name on it:
It seems unthinkable that even a man with a conspiratorial bent like Jimmy Lee Dykes, Ethan’s kidnapper, would bear a violent impulse against the familiar small-town universe of school buses and name tags. And it seems hard to imagine, in turn, that this universe could stand up under Mr. Dykes’s sort of violence. But over the past week, as the world of pot luck dinners and prayer meetings joined with the lethal efficiency of elite law enforcement, Mr. Dykes fought and lost.
Which leaves me wondering: Do Brown and Campbell seriously believe that the outcome would have been different had this happened in a metropolitan area rather than in little ol' Midland City?  Was it the small town solidarity and prayer--or the "lethal efficiency of elite law enforcement"--that made the difference?

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Selling trucks, shortchanging reality

Chrysler’s ad for the new Dodge Ram was arresting from the first moment. The crackle of an old radio marked a departure from the Super Bowl’s diet of anthropomorphic, snack-food loving animals and club scenes touting Budweiser’s latest iteration. The commercial’s aged patina and no-nonsense narration evoked a pared-down, no-nonsense America.

The ad featured late radio broadcaster Paul Harvey delivering his 1978 homage to the American farmer over a slideshow of classic farm scenes. “And on the eighth day,” Harvey declared, “God looked down on his planned paradise and said, ‘I need a caretaker.’ So God made a farmer.” The slideshow is unabashed Americana: pickups and barns, prairie churches and weathered farmers.

Chrysler’s play at returning us to our rural roots was heralded as a marketing triumph by most in the industry. Heartland politicos were understandably tickled: even Iowa’s Governor Terry Brandstad joined the media chorus, quipping that he “thought it was one of the best ads that aired during the Super Bowl.”

Once our plucked heartstrings settled, however, some began to see something subversive. The ad painted a portrait of American farm life that is racially homogeneous and dominated by the family farm. The brief flash of a darker-skinned family in the middle of the ad only made the discrepancy starker.

Agricultural America isn’t all white – fully half of farmworkers are Hispanic – and the family farm hasn’t dominated rural economies for quite some time. Taken as homage to those producing our food, this commercial clearly comes up short. The Atlantic broke from the general gushing, deriding Chrysler’s trumpeting of outdated rural tropes as 'whitewashing':
Now, did God make Mexican farmworkers or only white farmers? Is the strength and toughness that comes from hard work God's gift to white people only? [...] the way this ad whitewashed American farming leaves Mexican farmworkers and their children "excluded from the process of patriotism[.]"
Other criticisms were more tempered. Here's what NPR had to say:
Despite these objections, one thing is for sure: For two captivating minutes Sunday night, the values and future of American farming left the sidelines of the popular conversation to dominate a very, very large stage.
I felt quite the opposite. While I enjoyed the commercial and Paul Harvey’s rousing speech, the commercial did little to shed light on the issues facing rural America. By valorizing a narrow slice of rural America, I think Chrysler actually contributed to a broader cognitive dissonance between the myth and reality of rural America. I think waving images of Grant Wood's rural America to sell trucks is harmful because it inoculates us against a full discussion of the issues. This ad belongs in the canon of cultural references to the half-truths of the rural myth discussed on this blog.

Assuaged by the myth of Paul Harvey’s Heartland, we seem largely content to put rural immigration issues and poverty aside. The close association between white farmers and agrarian values only stokes the passions of those who believe these values are under siege by the latest tide of immigrant farmworkers. Public perception of agriculture also certainly contributes to the untouchable nature of the farm bill. The American food production system is often inhumane, irresponsible, and inefficient, yet metro-centric media continues to fetishize a rural reality that simply isn’t.

Chrysler is pledging up to one million dollars derived from ad views to FFA, an organization dedicated to agricultural education and the original audience of Paul Harvey’s speech. They’re a fine organization, albeit not one terribly inclusive of minorities, but I’m left wishing Chrysler did more. Between this commercial and their paeans to Detroit from Super Bowls past (we’ll ignore their military exploitation misstep), Chrysler has proven masterful at spinning narratives that insert itself in the fabric of our dearest American myths. I wish they’d go a step further and shed some of that storytelling power on American reality.

China premier's visit casts spotlight on rural poverty

The New York Times ran a story on January 27 about Chinese Premier Xi Jinping's visit to Luotuowan,  "a remote mountain hamlet in north China" in Hebei Province, a place the story characterizes as marked by "grinding poverty."  Andrew Jacobs writes:  
With a gaggle of local party chiefs and photographers in tow, Mr. Xi ducked into ramshackle farmhouses, patted dirt-smudged children on the head and, with little prompting, nibbled on a potato plucked from Tang Rongbin’s twig-fueled cooking fire. 
“It was as if we had met Mao,” said a still-incredulous Mr. Tang, 69, who shares a bed with five family members.
Jacobs explains that the visit, which was broadcast nationally, was intended to show Xi's "concern for China's rural poor" and to "burnish the new leader's bona fides as an empathetic man of the people." 
“I want to know how rural life is here,” he said at one point as the camera lingered on the unvarnished details of the Tang family’s poverty: a single light bulb, a tattered straw ceiling, a huddle of grimy pots and mounds of detritus. “I want to see real life.”
In the aftermath of this visit, Jacobs reports, money and gifts have flowed into Luotuowan.  The government sent $160 in cash, a bottle of cooking oil, and sack of rice to each household.  A businessman drove 500 miles to Luotuowan to deliver more cash and a "car load of flat-screen televisions."  A government work crew came to do some sprucing up.  Finally, government researchers came, having been instructed "to solve Luotuowan's intractable poverty, perhaps by pursuing Mr. Xi's suggestion that, with outside expertise, "the people can make yellow soil into gold."  Whatever that means.  The village is home, Jacobs reports, to about 600 corn farmers.  Jacobs also focuses on Xi's "secretary of the people" demeanor, including his ability to rub elbows comfortably with "farmers and factory workers." 

Searching for this story, which I read when it was first published, brought me to many other stories about rural China in the New York Times, including this one from yesterday, "Satellites Put Small Farms on China's Map."  Lucy Hornby and Hui Li report:
[T]he tiny village [of Yangwang] in Anhui Province was home to a pilot project that for the first time mapped farmers’ land, putting Yangwang on the front line of China’s efforts to build a modern agricultural sector that can underpin the country’s food security — a policy priority for the Communist Party. 
The mapping is a tedious but crucial task to make farmers feel more secure about their rights so that they become more willing to merge fields into larger-scale farms. It could also help protect them from land grabs by local officials, a leading cause of rural unrest.  
Last week China released its annual rural policy document, which "calls for farmland titles to be defined nationwide during the next five years," a project that could cost $16 billion. The Chinese government also introduced "sweeping tax reforms ... to narrow a wide income gap between the urban elite and the rural poor." This separate story from last week discusses the rural-urban income gap in the country, referring to "public concern about the gap between the incomes of residents of dirt-poor villages and those living in privileged urban enclaves."

Other headlines over the years suggest considerable attention to rural poverty in China.  Here are just a smattering of those that pop up from searching "rural China" on the NYTimes website:













Sunday, February 3, 2013

Fracking in the news, from Colorado to California

A story out of Paonia, Colorado is here, and the one out of Fellows, California, is here.

Jack Healy reports from Paonia, in the North Fork Valley, about leases for 114,932 acres of federal land in Colorado, leases that will be auctioned off in March as part of the Obama administration's effort to increase domestic natural gas production.
For a glimpse into the complications of President Obama’s “all of the above” energy policy, follow a curling mountain road through the aspens and into central Colorado’s North Fork Valley, where billboards promote “gently grown” fruits and farmers sell fresh milk and raw honey from pay-what-you-can donation boxes. 
Here, amid dozens of organic farms, orchards and ranches, the federal government is opening up thousands of acres of public land for oil and gas drilling, part of its largest energy lease sale in Colorado since Mr. Obama took office. 
Coloradans in solidly red cities west of here are the ones who have written letters to the government supporting the lease sale, saying it will bring jobs and tax revenues. In Paonia, where political lines are more evenly split, residents have come out overwhelmingly against the idea of drilling, saying it threatens a new economy rooted in tourism, wineries and organic peaches.
Landon Dean, an area dairy farmer, says she has been thinking of sowing hops for organic beer.  But one parcel that is up for lease sits directly below her fields, and she's worried about keeping her land suitable for organic farming.  She is quoted:
It’s just this land-grab, rape-and-pillage mentality. ... All it takes is one spill, and we're toast. 
Read more about fracking in Colorado here.

An excerpt from Norimitsu Onishi's story out of Kern County, California follows:
Comprising two-thirds of the United States’s total estimated shale oil reserves and covering 1,750 square miles from Southern to Central California, the Monterey Shale could turn California into the nation’s top oil-producing state and yield the kind of riches that far smaller shale oil deposits have showered on North Dakota and Texas. 
For decades, oilmen have been unable to extricate the Monterey Shale’s crude because of its complex geological formation, which makes extraction quite expensive. But as the oil industry’s technological advances succeed in unlocking oil from increasingly difficult locations, there is heady talk that California could be in store for a new oil boom.
While the dateline is in Kern County, California's oil and gas capital, it seems clear that the Monterey Shale could invite fracking across a very large region of central California.

Boom and bust: energy and health in North Dakota


North Dakota is experiencing a huge oil boom due to new advancements in horizontal fracking techniques. Western North Dakota sits atop the Bakken oil formation, an area estimated to hold up to 34 million barrels of oil. At the highest count, the number of oil rigs present in North Dakota reached 218 last May.

Williston is an oil boom town in North Dakota. Rent there is comparable to rent prices in New York City: reaching almost $2000 for a one bedroom apartment. Towns in North Dakota cannot grow fast enough to meet the influx of new workers. Developers have set up ad hoc “man camps” which are dorm style living quarters for men who work in the oil fields.

Salaries for workers in the oil field average out to $70,000 and more than $100,000 with overtime. Job opportunities outside the oil fields are abundant as well. One fast-food restaurant has almost doubled its hourly wage to keep workers.

The oil boom in North Dakota has been compared to this century’s gold rush, North Dakota’s Silicon Valley. Journalists report that it is rare to find voices in opposition to the economic opportunities that come along with North Dakota’s new oil promise. Chip Brown from the NYTimes speaks with Professor Jenkinson, who voices his enthusiasm for the oil boom: “[The oil boom] reverses decades of anxiety about out-migration and rural decline and death . . . . We aren’t going to do anything to jeopardize it. People aren’t interested in stepping back.”

North Dakota has only 700,000 people and a whopping 1.5 billion dollars in its coffers. Unsurprisingly, the speed of development, investment and rapid job creation coincides with a spike in work related accidents and health problems. Medical facilities in North Dakota bear much of the economic brunt caused by uninsured laborers’ inability to pay for medical care. Many of the laborers are transient migrant workers with no official place of residence. As such, hospitals have trouble tracking these workers down to pay their hospital bills.

Not only is human health a growing issue in light of North Dakota’s oil boom, environmental health is a source of grave concern as well.

Investigation conducted by non-profit news outlet ProPublica reveals that there were more than “1,000 accidental releases of oil, drilling wastewater and other fluids” in 2011. You can use ProPublica’s tracker to see how many gallons of oil were spilled in 2011 alone. The amazing thing is that numbers are but reported numbers from energy companies and do not account for illicit dumping or unreported spillage.

The fraught imbalance between energy extraction, harm to human health, environmental degradation, and economic prosperity is an old tale. Boom and bust, rise and fall, it is important to remember that even within each “boom” there is always an irretrievable loss -- this is the inescapable reality of fossil fuel extraction. The story of this century’s “black gold” is still unfolding.

Friday, February 1, 2013

Family, business and American agriculture

In a recent speech, Bernie Erven emphasized the importance of hiring good workers, especially in the struggling farm industry. A central part of the movement to modern hiring practices focused on a movement away from traditional familial hiring practices. NPR's blog The Salt covered the speech and the potential implications of moving away from hiring from within families. In the article, Jessica Stoller-Conrad noted that the argument to hire in a more "professional" way would likely be a tough sell to most farmers in America.

With non-family farms making up only 2% of the farms in America, the movement away from employing family members would present a drastic demographic shift. While the designation of family farm does not necessarily mean that all employees of the farm would be family members, the shift away from predominately hiring family members could present a dramatic departure from family farm traditions. The USDA defines a family farm as having a substantial amount of labor provided by the family.

Erven spoke directly to the employment of family members, noting that it is essential to still interview family members when hiring them to work on family farms. While interviewing family members prior to hiring may result in more qualified people being hired, a shift away from having a substantial amount of labor be performed by family may result in the farm failing to meet USDA's definition of a family farm. Beyond the legal requirements and implications on farm loan programs, the decreased availability of jobs may end up encouraging young members of rural communities to migrate to urban areas to find jobs.

From a purely economic lens, Erven's argument likely has merit. Hiring skilled farmworkers as opposed to under-qualified family members may appear to economists as the most sound economic choice. While the Farm Bill has been extended for another year, the delay in passing the House of Representatives may indicate an uncertain future for farm subsidies. The introduction of hiring practices that are focused on qualifications instead of familial connections may appeal to those who are focused on the American farm as an economic driver. But can the farms of rural America be reduced to solely economic entities?

A conversation concerning the current or ideal role of farms in American society is perhaps more appropriate in a longer post. However, attempts by the Federal Government around family and agriculture could frame the discussion in interesting ways.

In June of 2011, U.S Fish & Wildlife Services hosted public meetings to discuss the purchasing of conservation easements in California's Central Valley. The project being called the California Foothills Legacy Area and is being marketed as a way for ranching families to stay on their land while protecting the land for wildlife. Many private property rights advocate groups and the California Cattleman's Association came out in opposition of the project. Strong opposition has also been voiced over the past year by private citizens who described the project as the "federal government's greedy hand."

It is interesting to think about the California Foothills Legacy Area's presentation of family as a central reason for the project. The focus on family as an integral aspect of American rangeland echoes the centrality of family in American farmlands. Despite the current centrality of the identity of family in farms and rangeland, shifting demographics and migration is changing the make-up of rural communities. Would a shift away from a central identity of family change the place of farms and ranges in American culture?

North Dakota now

Don't miss Chip Brown's piece, "North Dakota Went Boom" in this week-end's NYTimes Magazine. I like this excerpt:
It’s hard to think of what oil hasn’t done to life in the small communities of western North Dakota, good and bad. It has minted millionaires, paid off mortgages, created businesses; it has raised rents, stressed roads, vexed planners and overwhelmed schools; it has polluted streams, spoiled fields and boosted crime. It has confounded kids running lemonade stands: 50 cents a cup but your customer has only hundreds in his payday wallet. Oil has financed multimillion-dollar recreation centers and new hospital wings. It has fitted highways with passing lanes and rumble strips. It has forced McDonald’s to offer bonuses and brought job seekers from all over the country — truck drivers, frack hands, pipe fitters, teachers, manicurists, strippers. It has ginned up an unreleased reality show called “Boomtown Girls,” which follows the lives of “five bold and brave sisters” in the formerly drowsy farm center of Williston, N.D. Williston, whose population has tripled in the past 10 years, lies in the middle of the 150,000-square-mile Williston Basin, a depression in the crust of the earth that geologists now believe contains one of the largest oil fields in the world.

More rural v. urban in the gun control debate

Like other journalists in recent days (read more here and here), Dan Frosch suggests a rural-urban divide on the issue of gun control in this story in today's New York Times.  The headline is "Some Sheriffs Object to Call for Tougher Gun Laws," and the gist of Frosch's spin on rural-urban difference regarding this very current issue follows:
Over the past several weeks, dozens of other sheriffs from across the country have reacted with similar public opposition to Mr. Obama’s call for stiffer gun laws, releasing a deluge of letters, position papers and statements laying out their arguments in stark terms. Their jurisdictions largely include rural areas, and stand in sharp contrast to those of urban police chiefs, who have historically supported tougher gun regulations. 
* * *  
Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum, which generally supports changes in gun laws, said that because sheriffs are often in charge of local jails and deal with mentally ill inmates, they were also more likely to view mental health as the most pressing concern. 
Mr. Wexler, whose group researches law enforcement issues in major cities, said urban police chiefs had long been more receptive to gun control measures because they handled gun crime on an everyday basis.
Beyond these differences between what sheriffs see and do and what city police chiefs see and do, Frosch's story, dateline Denver, suggests that gun culture is just different in rural places.  He provides some colorful quotes from the sheriffs  of Weld and Larimer counties in Colorado.  

The former said,
I don’t plan on helping or assisting with any of the federal gun laws because I have the U.S. Supreme Court and the U.S. Constitution on my side. ... Let the federal government do their own dirty work.
The latter wrote in a post to his Facebook page,
As Sheriff, I will not enforce unconstitutional federal laws.
Oh, and there's a colorful photo of the Weld County sheriff, surrounded by men in--you guessed it--cowboy hats.

Yet its worth noting that both Weld County is part of the Combined Denver-Aurora-Boulder Metropolitan Statistical Area, and Larimer County is in the Fort Collins-Loveland Metropolitan Statistical Area.  The former is the ninth most populous county in the state, the latter the sixth most populous.