Wednesday, July 17, 2024

"Rural" makes an appearance in chatter about J.D. Vance, but not in his convention speech

This is from the New York Times right now:  

Live Election Updates: J.D. Vance Addresses Republican Convention

A night focused on foreign policy featured fiery denouncements of President Biden on his policies and age. Donald Trump Jr., the former president’s son, assailed Democrats and the president.

Here’s what’s happening:

In the biggest speech of his political career, Senator J.D. Vance connected his difficult upbringing in rural Ohio to challenges now confronting the working class, decrying Democratic policies and Wall Street.

To be clear, Middletown, Ohio, population 50,000, is not rural by any measure.  Also, Vance did not himself use the word "rural" in his speech. 

Here's a report from The Hill's live reporting on Vance's speech, which played to "rural" and/or "hillbilly" themes:

Vance shared a story about his grandmother that drew loud applause from the audience.

“My Mamaw died shortly before I left for Iraq in 2005, and when we went through her things we found 19 loaded handguns,” Vance said, prompting cheers and chants of “Mamaw.”

“Now, the thing is, they were stashed all over her house … This frail old woman made sure that no matter where she was, she was within arm’s length of whatever she needed to protect her family,” Vance said as the crowd cheered. 
— Julia Mueller

This is a quote from the NewYork Times story about Usha Vance's introduction of her husband's acceptance speech (emphasis mine):  

She leaned into the story about her husband’s impoverished upbringing and the laws of opposites attracting, highlighting their different backgrounds.

“When J.D. met me, he approached our differences with curiosity and enthusiasm,” Ms. Vance said. “He wanted to know everything about me, where I came from, what my life had been like.”

The couple met at Yale Law School, where Ms. Vance helped Mr. Vance organize his ideas about social decline in rural white America, the basis of his breakout memoir, “Hillbilly Elegy.” They were married in 2014 in Kentucky and have three children. She is the daughter of Indian immigrants.

Here's an interesting tweet from the right, but it doesn't ring true.  

I exist in a very lefty media ecosystem, and I've not (yet) seen the left talking of Vance's "insufficiencies."  I've not seen his class of origin made an issue--nor, as of yet, any "insufficiency."  What I am seeing made an issue of is Vance's increasingly intolerant leanings.  

1 comment:

  1. Howdy Guys

    If you are in searching of Legit vendor for Fullz you are at right place
    Just try my stuff you'll never be disappointed
    Although, I'm giving replacement for the bad stuff as well

    USA UK CANADA Fresh Fullz Info Pros Leads Available
    All States & Cities info are available
    Young Age, Old age, Mid age,, Every age you can asked
    Real DL scan with selfie proof available
    Fullz Pros with dl issue & Expiry dates available as well

    Each & Every type of Fullz Pros Leads of USA UK CANADA you can get from my shop
    Samples are also available for bulk buyers & for testing
    No scam, will show you proof of everything as well

    Contact me for the best deals & discounts
    24/7 available for you

    What's App - +1.. 7277.. 886.. 129..
    Tele - @ leadsupplier & @ killhacks
    Skype - @ peeterhacks
    E mail - cyber.zoneuniverse at g mail . com

    Fresh Spammed available in Thousands & Millions
    Stuff will be provided within 10 mins after payment proof
    Guarantee for the stuff Info & Validity

    USA SSN DOB DL ADDRESS EMPLOYEE & BANK INFO FULLZ LEADS
    UK NIN DOB DL ADDRESS SORT CODE ACCOUNT NUMBER FULLZ
    CANADA SIN DOB DL MMN PHONE EMAIL FULLZ
    DL SCAN ORIGINAL FRONT & BACK WITH SELFIE
    BUSINESS EIN COMPANY FULLZ
    OLD & YOUNG AGE PROS
    STUDENTS PROS IN BULK
    HIGH CREDIT SC PROS FULLZ 700+
    FULLZ WITH SSN DL MVR
    DL FULLZ WITH ISSUE & EXP DATES
    EMAIL & PHONE NUMBER & BANK INFO LEADS USA UK CANADA
    CC WITH CVV & DUMPS WITH PINS
    CARDING & CASH OUT METHODS WITH TUTORIALS
    SPAM-MMING TUTORIALS WITH TOOLS & LEADS
    OFFICE365 LEADS & LOGINS

    Quantity with Quality stuff available
    Payment only in Crypto & Cash app

    ReplyDelete